How to Make Homemade Brown Sugar

As part of our Homemade Pantry series, today I’m sharing a super-easy and satisfying kitchen staple you can whip up in just a few minutes. Homemade brown sugar is rich, soft, and incredibly simple to make using just two ingredients. Once you try making it yourself, you may never go back to store-bought again.

Why Make Homemade Brown Sugar?

Making your own brown sugar at home gives you full control over the quality of your ingredients. You can avoid unnecessary additives and ensure your sugar stays fresh and flavorful. It also helps you skip those stressful last-minute trips to the store when you realize you’re out.

This simple kitchen trick is perfect for anyone who values pantry preparedness or enjoys stocking up on homemade staples. Keeping a well-stocked pantry means fewer store runs and more time doing what you love—cooking from scratch. All you need is granulated sugar and molasses. In less than five minutes, you’ll have soft, moist brown sugar ready to use in any recipe.

Ingredients You’ll Need to Make Homemade Brown Sugar

To make homemade brown sugar, you only need two basic ingredients:

• 3 cups white granulated sugar
• ¼ cup unsulphured molasses

For the best results, be sure to use unsulphured molasses, which is the standard type available at most grocery stores like Walmart. It has a rich, robust flavor without being overly bitter. Blackstrap molasses and regular molasses differ in color, thickness, sugar content, and overall flavor. Each type comes from a different stage in the sugar refining process, which affects its sweetness and texture.

Blackstrap molasses is the darkest and thickest variety. It’s also the least sweet, with a bold, bitter flavor that comes from being boiled three times during sugar production. This concentrated process gives it a robust taste and higher mineral content. Regular molasses, often labeled as “dark molasses,” is boiled twice. It’s sweeter and less intense than blackstrap but still thicker and richer than light molasses, which is only boiled once and has the mildest flavor of the three.

Tools Required to Make Homemade Brown Sugar

You’ll need a large food processor that holds at least 6 cups to easily blend the sugar and molasses together. Using a food processor ensures the ingredients incorporate smoothly and quickly.

If you don’t have a food processor, you can mix them by hand with a sturdy fork or electric mixer, but it will take a little more effort to fully combine.

Step-by-Step Instructions

1. Place the granulated sugar and molasses into the food processor.
2. Blend on high speed for about 1 minute.
3. Remove half of the sugar from the food processor and place it in a bowl.
4. Continue blending the remaining sugar for another minute or until no major molasses lumps remain.
5. Remove the processed sugar and place it in its own bowl.
6. Add the reserved sugar back into the processor and blend for another minute, again making sure no large lumps remain.
7. Combine both sets of sugar together, and your homemade brown sugar is ready to use.

Tips for Storing Homemade Brown Sugar

Store your brown sugar in an airtight kitchen container on the counter. It will stay fresh and soft for up to two months. If you live in a humid or dry climate, consider adding a moisture absorber, like a terra cotta brown sugar saver, to help prevent clumping.

Do not freeze homemade brown sugar, as freezing can change its texture and cause it to dry out faster once thawed.

Troubleshooting: What If I See Tiny Molasses Lumps?

You might notice small molasses lumps in your finished brown sugar. This is perfectly normal and doesn’t affect the quality or taste. If you prefer a completely smooth texture, simply blend the sugar a little longer until the lumps disappear.

Final Thoughts

Homemade brown sugar is a quick, simple way to build your pantry with ingredients you can trust. It’s moist, flavorful, and perfect for baking, sweetening sauces, or sprinkling over oatmeal. Plus, it feels good knowing you made it yourself with just a few minutes of effort.

Stay tuned for more Homemade Pantry recipes as we continue to build a kitchen full of homemade basics.